Spontaneous attentional failures reflect multiplicative interactions of chronic sleep loss with acute sleep loss and circadian misalignment.

Objectives: Acute and chronic sleep loss and circadian timing interact such that, depending on their combination, small or very large performance decrements are observed in tasks of attention. Here, we tested whether such nonlinear interactions extend to a physiological measure of spontaneous visual attentional failures, indicating a fundamental principle of sleep-wake regulation.

Methods: Nine healthy volunteers completed an in-laboratory 3-week forced desynchrony protocol consisting of 12 consecutive 42.85-hour cycles with a sleep-wake ratio of 1:3.3. The protocol induced increasing chronic sleep loss, while extended wake (32.85 hours) and sleep episodes (10 hours) occurred at multiple circadian phases. Attentional failure rate was quantified from continuous electrooculograms (number of 30-second epochs with slow eye movements/h of wakefulness) as a function of time since scheduled wake (acute sleep loss), week of study (chronic sleep loss), and circadian (melatonin) phase.

Results: During the first ∼8 hours awake, attentional failure rate was low, irrespective of the week. During the following wake hours, attentional failure rate increased steadily but at a faster rate in weeks 2 and 3 compared to week 1. The effects of acute and chronic sleep loss on attentional failure rate were magnified during the biological night compared to the biological day.

Conclusions: A single extended sleep episode can only temporarily reverse attentional impairment associated with chronic sleep loss. Multiplicative effects of acute and chronic sleep loss-further amplified during the biological night-substantiate the interaction of 2 homeostatic response mechanisms and caution against underestimating their disproportionate combined impact on performance, health, and safety.