Increased Synthetic Cytotoxicity of Combinatorial Chemoradiation Therapy in Homologous Recombination Deficient Tumors.

Purpose: Homologous recombination deficient (HRD) tumors are exquisitely sensitive to platinum-based chemotherapy and when combined with radiation therapy (RT), leads to improved overall survival in multiple cancer types. Whether a subset of tumors with distinct molecular characteristics demonstrate increased benefit from cisplatin and RT (c-RT) is unclear. We hypothesized that HRD tumors, whether associated with BRCA mutations or genomic scars of HRD, exhibit exquisite sensitivity to c-RT, and that HRD may be a significant driver of c-RT benefit.

Methods And Materials: Sensitivity to c-RT was examined using isogenic and sporadic breast cancer cell lines. HRD was assessed using 4 assays: RT-induced Rad51 foci, a DR-GFP reporter assay, a genomic scar score (large-scale state transitions [LST]), and clonogenic survival assays. Whole-genome sequencing of 4 breast tumors from a phase 2 clinical trial of neoadjuvant c-RT in triple-negative breast cancer was performed and HRD was defined using HRDetect.

Results: BRCA1/2 deficient cell lines displayed functional HRD based on the Rad51 functional assay, with c-RT to RT or cisplatin interaction ratios (IR) of 1.11 and 26.84 for the BRCA1 isogenic pair at 2 μM cisplatin and 6 Gy, respectively. The highest LST lines demonstrated HRD and synthetic cytotoxicity to c-RT with IR at 2 Gy and cisplatin 20 μM of 7.50, and the lowest LST line with IR of 0.65. Of 4 evaluable patients in the phase 2 trial, one achieved a pathologic complete response with corresponding HRD based on multiple genomic scar scores including HRDetect and LST scores, compared with patients without a pathologic complete response.

Conclusions: HRD breast cancers, whether identified by BRCA1/2 mutation status, functional tests, or mutational signatures, appear to be significantly more sensitive to c-RT compared with isogenic controls or tumors without HRD mutational signatures. HRD tumors may be exquisitely sensitive to c-RT which warrants further clinical investigation to guide a precision oncology approach.