Comparison of the Simplexa GBS Direct and ARIES GBS assays for the detection of in broth-enriched swab specimens.

We conducted a comparative evaluation of the FDA-cleared Simplexa GBS Direct and ARIES GBS molecular assays for the detection of (Group B , GBS) in 386 prospectively collected, broth-enriched vaginal/rectal swab specimens. The sensitivity of each test was 96.2% and specificity was ≥98.7% when compared to a combined direct and enriched culture method using chromogenic culture medium. A total of four specimens were called positive by both molecular assays but negative by culture, likely representing specimens with a low burden of GBS in these specimens. Two specimens were reported positive by culture but negative by both molecular assays. One of these specimens demonstrated atypically colored colonies on chromogenic agar; the other yielded typically colored colonies only observed after broth enrichment. Our data demonstrate equivalent performance of Simplexa and ARIES molecular assays for the detection of GBS in clinical specimens.IMPORTANCEClinical laboratories often face decisions regarding which of the multiple available molecular platforms would best fit their needs based on cost, workflow, menu, and diagnostic performance. Therefore, objective clinical comparisons of similar molecular tests are valuable resources to aid these decisions. We provide a clinical comparison of two FDA-cleared tests to routine culture and to each other that can be used by clinical laboratories when determining which of the available molecular platforms would best fit their laboratory in terms of workflow, cost, and performance.